Emmental, or Emmentaler, is a hard cheese originating from Switzerland, named after the Emme Valley (Emmental in German) in the eastern part of the canton of Bern. The term « Emmental » is also used for similar cheeses produced industrially or under various labels in other countries. This cow’s milk cheese is known for its cooked pressed texture. The characteristic holes are caused by tiny hay particles that enter the milk during milking. During fermentation, these particles release gases that form the holes seen in the final product. A Swiss Emmentaler AOP cheese wheel typically weighs around 90 kg. The large size of these wheels dates back to the 19th century when customs duties were levied per unit rather than by weight. Generally, the cheese is aged for an average of seven weeks, but for a stronger flavor, it can be aged for 8 to 12 months. Emmental is one of the most consumed cheeses in Switzerland, alongside Gruyère, and is also one of the most widely known and exported cheeses globally.
The production area includes the canton of Bern and many other Swiss-German cantons, extending to the German-speaking part of the canton of Fribourg. Emmental AOP is produced according to very specific guidelines, with approximately 149 companies in Switzerland currently producing Emmental AOC. Today, the production of Gruyère AOC slightly surpasses that of Emmental AOC. Nevertheless, Emmental AOC remains Switzerland’s most exported cheese, with twice the export volume of Gruyère AOC.
Swiss nationals often critique the production of these cheeses outside of Switzerland, similar to Gruyère cheese. Nowadays, industrial cheese similar to Emmental is produced under the generic name « Emmental » in Germany, Austria, Denmark, the United States, the Netherlands, and France. The total European industrial production is around 464,000 tons, representing about 6% of these countries’ milk collection, significantly more than Switzerland’s production of approximately 25,000 tons per year. Since 1999, France has been recognized as the world’s leading producer of this cheese, with about 110,000 tons annually, half of which is produced in Brittany.
The feud between the Swiss and the French over cheese production is far from over. For a long time, French industrial Emmental was marketed in France under the generic name « Gruyère. » The confusion arose because, unlike Swiss Gruyère, French Gruyère contains holes, similar to Emmental. In the mid-19th century, Bernese merchants introduced Emmental to the French market as Gruyère, causing the mix-up. Despite Emmental being claimed as a French cheese, it has no French origin. The same story applies to Gruyère, also claimed by the French, but with holes, unlike Swiss Gruyère. This infuriates the Swiss, who rely on AOP labels to protect their products. The French, ever claiming to have invented everything, remain incorrigible. If one delves deeper, the cows’ diets should also be considered. In Switzerland, Simmental cows provide the milk, grazing on grass in summer and hay in winter. In France, mostly Holstein cows are used, which are typically kept indoors and fed corn. The choice is yours, gastronomes.